Whine Club
Aired 24th February 2000 · Written by Bob Daily & Jon Sherman · Directed by Kelsey Grammer
Clare
How's your coffee?
Martin
Good, good. Yours?
Clare
Very nice.
Martin
That's good.
Clare
[then] Marty, we have no reason to be uncomfortable. We're two consenting adults.
Martin
What about your husband? He never consented!
Clare
Stan loved you Martin, and he loved me. If anything, he's up in heaven right now, watching us and smiling.
Martin
You don't think he was watching the whole time, do you?
Clare
Not if heaven gets ESPN! [they laugh] Now, stop feeling guilty.
Martin
Okay.
Frasier
Oh, Dad.
Martin
[worried] Oh, Fras'. You remember Clare Wojadubakowski?
Frasier
Yes, of course, hello, Mrs. Wojadubakowski, good to see you again. Gosh, I'm sorry again about your loss.
Clare
Thank you.
Frasier
He was a good man, your husband. [Martin's guilt starts] Dad's often said if it weren't for Stan, he wouldn't have made it through the academy, isn't that right?
Martin
[guilty] That's right.
Frasier
Didn't he lend you the money for your first car?
Martin
Yeah, he did.
Frasier
Oh course, we all owe him for introducing Dad to Mom.
Martin
Oh, God!
Clare
You know, Marty, I think we better go.
Frasier
Of course, well, Clare it's lovely seeing you again. Em, please give my regards to your son, Martin.
Martin
Oh, God!
Frasier
Oh hi, Roz. Why don't you join me?
Roz
Well, aren't you here with Niles?
Frasier
No, actually I haven't been seeing much of Niles lately. He spends all his time with Mel.
Roz
Well, that's what happens at the beginning of relationships. [to waiter] Can I have a decaf latte, please?
Frasier
[to waiter] Yes, and I'll have my usual, thank you. [waiter leaves] Yes, I do hope he hasn't forgotten me completely. We have wine club tonight, I'm sort of counting on him to help me become "corkmaster."
Roz
But you'll still keep your secret identity as Frasier Crane, right?
Frasier
Corkmaster's the most prestigious position in our club. If elected, I plan to have vertical tastings and guest speakers, perhaps even a trip to Portugal where some of the world's finest corks come from.
Roz
I wish I had a cork right now!
Frasier
Very funny, Roz. You know what, I do hope Niles shows up. You know, Mel has a way of making him change his mind at the last minute. You know, I think she's a bit manipulative.
Roz
Based on what?
Frasier
Oh, I don't know, I've a feeling.
Roz
So you really don't know her that well.
Frasier
That's true. You know, I really haven't given her much of a chance, I suppose. I suppose I could put together a little get-to-know-you event, a Sunday brunch perhaps?
Roz
There you go.
Frasier
Yes, it's a good idea, Roz. Of course, I don't want to make it seem like she's under the family microscope. You know, maybe you could come along.
Roz
I guess I could.
Frasier
Great.
Roz
Oh, and by Sunday you'll be Corkman.
Frasier
Cork-MASTER, thank you, Roz. [laughs] Actually, I won't know until after the election tonight. But you know, I'll let you know.
Roz
Or I could just look up into the sky for the cork signal!
Frasier
Very amusing, Roz.
Roz
If you win, I'd love a ride in the cork-mobile.
Frasier
All right, Roz!
Mel
[o.s.] Niles! [enters] Oh, don't you look dashing. I've brought you a nice bottle of Cheval Blanc to impress the wine club. Mrs. Briggs gave it to me as a thank-you after her last face-lift.
Niles
[looks at bottle] '61! I don't believe it!
Mel
Yes, that's what they're saying about Mrs. Briggs!
Niles
Oh, this is the perfect occasion for me to bring this wine. We're electing a new president tonight.
Mel
Oh?
Niles
Yes, and I promised Frasier I'd nominate him. Oh, did I mention, brunch at Frasier's tomorrow?
Mel
Oh yes, darling. Well, I'm so happy my rare, expensive bottle will benefit your brother. Oh, that tie's all wrong, let me.
Niles
Yes, of course, of course.
Niles
Yes, well, ever since the day he joined the wine club, Frasier's dreamed of becoming corkmaster. [she picks out a tie] Oh, good choice!
Mel
I think it's wonderful. I really do: helping your brother win this prestigious post.
Niles
Well, Frasier, deserves it.
Mel
Because he knows more about wine than you do?
Niles
I wouldn't say that.
Mel
Well, he's probably been in the club longer?
Niles
No, actually, I sponsored his membership.
Mel
Oh, well, so you've never wanted that honor for yourself?
Niles
Well, I wouldn't say never. Who hasn't nursed the dream of one day becoming corkmaster?
Mel
Oh, I'm sure Frasier at least asked if you were interested. [puts tie onto him]
Niles
Now that you mention it, no he didn't.
Mel
Oh, and you don't resent it? Well, you see, that's why I love you, because most people would. I would, bitterly, but then I'm not you and I don't know what's best for you and... now the jacket's all wrong. [takes it off him]
Niles
Do you think I should call him on this?
Mel
[getting another jacket] Please, the last thing I want to do is come between you and your brother.
Niles
He knows perfectly well how much I've coveted this post. I distinctly confided my aspirations to him the night Jud Riverton fell off the ferry after the spring tasting!
Mel
Well, I'm sure he just forgot.
Niles
No, no, don't defend him. Here. [lets her put the jacket on] He's always putting himself first and I always let him.
Mel
Why, Niles?
Niles
Oh, I don't know, I think perhaps it's because...
Mel
I'll tell you why: because you can't see yourself for what you really are! [holds him up into the mirror] You are a powerful, sexy, dynamic, colossus of a man. In other words, perfect corkmaster.
Niles
[looking at himself] I am, aren't I?
Mel
And don't let anyone, anyone ever take that away from you.
Mel
Now, that's all I want to say, because I love you and I don't want to meddle.
Frasier
Oh, Niles, finally, you're here.
Niles
Yes, sorry I'm late.
Frasier
Oh, that's all right, it's just that the nominations are about to begin. Now listen, this is what I thought we would do. After you nominate me, I will demure modestly for a moment and then I'll say something like...
Niles
I want to be corkmaster.
Frasier
Well, that's a bit artless, don't you think?
Niles
No, no: I want to be corkmaster too. I covet this post as much as you do, I always have, and I think I deserve a shot at it.
Frasier
But Niles, I've been campaigning for this all week, I was counting on you to nominate me.
Niles
And I will, I'm just hoping that you'll return the favor. Unless that is you're afraid of a little competition.
Master
Can I have your attention? My friends, as outgoing corkmaster, I would like to thank those who stuck with me during the ugly days of Spritzer-gate, but the time has come to pass the tasting cup. Are there any nominations? [Niles raises his hand] Niles.
Niles
It's a honor and a privilege to nominate my brother, Frasier Crane.
Master
Right, any others?
Frasier
[after some nudging] Yes, I would like to reciprocate and nominate my brother, Niles Crane.
Master
Are there any further nominations? [no-one raises a hand] Well then, a show of hands, please, for those in favor of Frasier Crane. [they do and he counts - including Niles's proud hand] Fourteen. And those in favor of Niles Crane? [they do - however Frasier does not raise his hand] Thirteen. [Niles stares at Frasier until he raises his hand] Oh, fourteen. It's a tie. If only out venerable founder, Virgil Hepplewhite was here to guide us.
Virgil
[out of nowhere] I'm over here.
Master
[crowd moves back] Oh, sorry, Virgil, I didn't see you. So, em, what is the procedure?
Virgil
[stands] Blind taste of five bottles.
Frasier
Oh for God's sake, Niles. The wine spent less time in the bottle! [Niles spits and writes down his prediction]
Master
All right, gentlemen, you have correctly identified the first three wines, let's see if number four can break the tie. Niles?
Niles
It was ripe, round and thoroughly seductive. I said Australian Shiraz. [holds up his card]
Master
Ah, and Frasier, what did you think?
Frasier
Well, contrary to my brother I thought it was dark, dusky and supple, but I also said Australian Shiraz." [holds up card]
Master
You're both right, we're still tied. [applause]
Frasier
Well, Niles, this is the moment of truth. Don't choke.
Niles
Please, prepare to be stomped like a late harvest Gevertstremener!
Master
Gentlemen?
Niles
It was jammy, plummy, dense and chewy. There is no doubt in my mind that it was a Napa Valley Merlot. [holds up card]
Master
You, Frasier.
Frasier
A nice big wine with excellent heft. It's Napa all right, but as I always say, why go Merlot when you can call a Cab? [holds up card]
Master
I thought this bottle might trip you up. Gentlemen, it's actually a blend. A forty-five percent Cabernet...
Frasier
And?!
Master
And... fifty five percent Merlot! Niles wins by ten percent.
Frasier
Well, Niles, congratulations, obviously the better man won.
Niles
Frasier, please...
Frasier
No, Niles, don't be modest.
Niles
No, I wasn't, they're starting my inauguration.
Club
Hail corkmaster, The master of the cork, He knows which wine goes with fish or pork! Hail corkmaster, The master of the cork...
Frasier
You know, the whole purpose of this brunch is to get to know Mel better, but it just hurts the hell out of me preparing a sumptuous brunch for Niles after the way he betrayed me at the wine club.
Roz
Oh, would you shut up about that corkmaster thing! I already hate you for putting that song in my head!
Martin
Okay, it's all clear.
Martin
[picks up chili bowl] Thanks for dropping off my tupperware.
Clare
Oh, oh, it's no trouble at all. I was headed out to church this morning... and I thought, "Oh, Marty's right on the way."
Martin
[snaps out of it] What's the matter with us?
Clare
Oh, Martin, we have done nothing wrong. I mean, maybe we were a little impetuous, but that's no crime.
Martin
Yeah, I guess you're right. Well, listen, thanks for dropping by, and I'll call you.
Frasier
Mrs. Wojadubakowski.
Martin
Yeah, look who just came here! Look who it is. [drags her back]
Frasier
I didn't even hear the doorbell ring, what brings you here?
Martin
Oh, [looks for excuse] she just brought me back my chili bowl. Well thanks a lot, and I'll see you later.
Frasier
No, Dad, where are your manners? Why don't you join us for brunch, Clare? I insist. I'm not sure that we'll be able to give you a treat as spicy as the one that Dad gave you but...
Clare
Yes, he does make very good chili!
Frasier
Isn't that flattering, Dad? You know what, I think someone wants seconds!
Martin
Frasier, could I see you in the kitchen for a minute?
Frasier
Yes, of course. Clare, you make yourself at home.
Frasier
Oh, splendid idea, Roz; Bloody Marys. You know, why don't you offer one of those to Clare?
Martin
Oh, I don't think she's got time.
Daphne
I'll ask her.
Daphne
[o.s.] Mrs. Wojadubakowski, Mr. Crane was wondering if you had time for a quick one.
Martin
[agitated] Look, Frasier, there's something you should know about me and Clare: we just slept together.
Frasier
Are you sure? She just got here two minutes ago.
Martin
She was here earlier. I just don't know what came over us. We just couldn't keep our hands off each other, we were like animals or sex-crazed teenagers.
Frasier
Well, what's wrong with that?
Martin
Well, I'll tell you what's wrong with that, she's Stan's widow. I mean, he didn't even like it when I borrowed his lawn mower!
Frasier
Dad, listen, Stan's been gone a while now. I mean, you're not teenagers, you're two mature people reaching out for some companionship. I think it's adorable. [doorbell sounds]
Martin
Adorable?!
Daphne
Oh, good morning, Dr. Crane.
Niles
Hello, Daphne. [looks] My, isn't that a beautiful outfit.
Daphne
[falling over herself] Oh, thank you, Dr. Crane, how sweet.
Mel
[on cell phone] So just beep me if you need me.
Niles
Greetings all. Mel, I think you know everyone.
Niles
Oh, Mrs. Wojadubakowski, what a nice surprise. This is Mel Karnovsky.
Mel
Hello.
Clare
It's a pleasure to meet you. [stands] Martin, I really have to be getting to church.
Martin
Oh, yeah, sure, okay. Well, I'll just walk you out.
Niles
You know what, by the way, I'm so sorry to hear about your husband.
Clare
Thank you, thank you.
Niles
I understand Dad's been doing what he can to fill the void.
Roz
Can I pour you a Bloody Mary, Mel?
Mel
Not for me. It's a little early in the day for hard liquor, don't you think?
Roz
Not anymore. [pours herself a large one]
Mel
Niles, let's get this foie gras box in the refrigerator. [notices Eddie has his head in the bag] Oh, hello, Eddie. Or should I say goodbye?
Martin
Huh?
Mel
Well, Martin, I'm sure you'll be locking Eddie out on the balcony if people are going to be eating here.
Martin
Well, I'll tell you who I'd like to lock out on the balcony-
Roz
Oh please, let it be me!
Frasier
Now, now, maybe I remind you that we're having this little bruncheon in order to get acquainted with Mel. We owe it to Niles to give her a chance.
Daphne
I agree with Dr. Crane, we should all have another Bloody Mary. [pours one]
Frasier
I didn't say that!
Daphne
It was implied.
Mel
[enters with Niles a bottle of wine] Oh, Frasier, I almost forgot. The corkmaster and I brought this along for you. [hands over bottle]
Frasier
Oh, well, thank you very much, that's a lovely bottle. I guess Niles must have told you about his eleventh hour victory.
Mel
Ah, yes, and I'm so proud of him.
Niles
Let's give credit where credit's due, to Mel. [kisses her]
Frasier
To Mel?
Niles
Well, yes, it was her idea that I should run.
Frasier
Really? Well, perhaps I'll just put this around the corner before the cork flies out and hits someone.
Mel
So, after all these years of doing tummy tucks and liposuctions, I can look at a fully clothed person and see exactly what they look like naked. [everyone becomes self- conscious] I can see every sag, droop, ripple and pucker. It's like X-ray vision.
Roz
How interesting. [walks to kitchen holding her stomach in] I think I'll go check on breakfast.
Frasier
[tensing his muscles] Let me give you a hand with that.
Roz
When you invited me, did you say "brunch for Mel" or "brunch from Hell"?
Frasier
That woman is unbearable.
Martin
[enters] Well, guess who's allergic to Eddie?
Frasier
Oh, Lord.
Martin
She wants a glass of water to take her pill with. [fills a glass] Boy, do you know what I can't stand? All that "sweetie, dearie, darling" stuff. I've never met anyone so phony! [Mel enters] Hello, dear, here's your water. [hands it over]
Mel
Thank you, Martin. Well, Frasier, I'm afraid I have some bad news. I just got beeped by my service and I have to go.
Frasier
Oh gosh, I'm so sorry.
Mel
Thank you for brunch though, thanks for inviting me. It's such a civilized way to spend an afternoon.
Daphne
"With her head tucked underneath her arm/ she walks the bloody tower!" - You know who that song's about, don't you?
Mel
Bloody Mary?
Daphne
Oh, don't mind if I do! [picks up Bloody Mary and exits]
Mel
Anyway, I better go.
Niles
Darling, I have your coat. I'll walk you to the elevator.
Mel
Well, thank you all for a lovely afternoon.
Martin
Well, that's a blessing. Now we can enjoy our breakfast.
Roz
I doubt it. I was only allowed to make a cheese-free, mushroom-free, fat-free frittata, thanks to the girl in the plastic bubble!
Daphne
I think I'll order a pizza. [takes phone into kitchen]
Frasier
You know, I have half a mind to say something to Niles, he is making a terrible mistake with that woman!
Martin
Frasier!
Frasier
But Dad, it is Maris all over again! She's dominating him, emasculating him!
Martin
Look, I don't like her anymore than you do and God knows we've been through this before. I didn't Lilith, we both didn't like Maris and you boys sure as hell didn't like Sherry, but what good did it do talking about it?
Frasier
He's repeating a terrible pattern.
Martin
Well he's going to repeat it whether you like it or not. And if you say anything, you're just going to drive a wedge between you. So, nobody's going to say a word!
Niles
Well, it's a shame Mel had to leave.
Frasier
Oh yeah, you know, we were having such a good time.
Martin
Yeah, Niles.
Niles
You know, I was nervous bringing her over here.
Niles
I was concerned what you'd think, you know, getting to really know her for the first time. So?
Roz
Ooh, I'm going to go let Eddie in. [exits to balcony]
Niles
Come on, seriously, I want you to be totally honest. [Daphne enters, waiting on the phone] Tell me, what do you think of Mel?
Daphne
Oh, I don't like her at all, she's bossy and fussy and mean. She's all wrong for you. [into phone] Yes, I need a large pepperoni pizza, and some cheese bread! [exits to kitchen]
Martin
[stands] I'm sure she didn't mean that, Niles. [follows Daphne into kitchen]
Niles
Well, that was startling.
Frasier
Yes, well, don't take that seriously, Niles. [Roz enters from balcony] You know how women sometimes just form irrational dislikes for one another.
Roz
Oh, that's great, I leave the room for one second and you rat me out.
Frasier
No, Roz...
Roz
No, it's okay, I don't have anything to hide and I'm not irrational. She's pushy, demanding and a gigantic pain in the ass! I'd dump her like radioactive waste.
Niles
Well, so that's two of you in the Anti-Mel camp.
Roz
[to Frasier] Oh, did you tell him what you thought of Mel too?
Frasier
No, Daphne did.
Roz
Oops! [exits to kitchen]
Niles
Frasier?!
Frasier
I just think she's Maris all over again, she's manipulative... I think you're repeating a terrible pattern.
Niles
Well, isn't this neat?! We all have our individual reasons for disliking her.
Niles
Hey, Dad, what's your reason for disliking Mel?
Daphne
So you did tell him what you think of her and after shoving me into the kitchen and shaking your freakin' finger at me!
Martin
She's crazy, Niles, I don't know what she's talking about... [Roz enters]
Niles
No, no, that's all right, Dad. I, er, I asked you all to be honest and you were. [gets coat] I got my answer. You know what would have been nice? Is if one of you could have found one nice thing to say about her.
Daphne
She does have that X-ray vision.
Martin
Did you talk to Niles?
Frasier
Em, I left a couple of messages but no answer. I think he's gonna have to stay mad for a while.
Martin
Yeah, well, that was a hell of a brunch all the way round for you as well as me.
Frasier
Dad, if you're talking about what happened between you and Mrs. Wojadubakowski, you have nothing to be ashamed of.
Martin
Yeah, yeah, I guess.
Frasier
So, you're going to see her again?
Martin
Oh, I don't know, I don't think it's gonna work out.
Frasier
You're not still feeling guilty, are you?
Martin
No, what you said made a lot of sense. It's just that I think it's run its course.
Frasier
Oh, well, I have a theory.
Martin
Geez!
Frasier
[Daphne enters and hears] No, no, hear me out. I think by giving you my approval to sleep with Clare I've made it less exciting for you. There was a certain illicitness to the relationship that gave it a kind of piquancy.
Martin
Frasier, it's Sunday, take the day off!
Daphne
[the drink has obviously worn off] Wait, Mr. Crane. You slept with Mrs. Wojadubakowski?
Martin
Yes, I did, isn't that adorable?
Daphne
No, it's disgusting, you dirty old man! Sleeping with that poor widow before her husband's even cold in the ground.
Martin
You think that was wrong?
Daphne
You're damn right I do. You ought to be ashamed.
Martin
See, I told you, Frasier.
Daphne
We live in a civilized society and there are certain rules we have to live by. [getting carried away as if settling a mental conflict] We all have impulses we'd like to explore, but we don't!
Frasier
Daphne?
Daphne
[after a pause she tries to put it aside] Well, we can't just go chasing anyone you fancy just because you're suddenly attracted to them. There are certain things you don't do, no matter how tempted you are. [exits to her room]
Frasier
Boy that was strange, wasn't it?
Martin
I don't think it was strange at all! Made a lot of sense to me! [stands and gets coat]
Frasier
Where the hell are you going?
Martin
Well, I better get over to Clare's and apologize. Don't wait up for me Frasier, I've got a lot of apologizing to do!